How To Break In New Leather Shoes
10/3/2025
Leather shoes, we love them. The majority of our range is crafted from leather - and for good reason. It’s breathable, durable and comfortable. While leather can sometimes feel stiff at first, with a little patience and care, it will soften and mould beautifully to your foot.
If you’ve ever wondered what breaking in shoes really means, it’s simply the process of allowing the leather to relax, stretch slightly and adapt to your unique foot shape. New shoes - particularly leather shoes and boots - can feel firm at first, but with the right steps, they’ll become your most comfortable pair.
Before we dive into how to break in leather shoes (and even patent leather), let’s cover why quality and fit matter most.
Why Quality Leather Matters
We use leather that’s initially on the firmer side. Why? Because while we design our shoes with comfort in mind, we also want them to last. Structured leather holds its shape, so you won’t end up with overstretched shoes that no longer support your feet.
All our leather uppers are sourced from Leather Working Group - rated tanneries. These follow strict protocols around water, energy and chemical management, ensuring our shoes meet the highest standards.
The beauty of leather is that it’s natural - it softens with time, flexes where you need it, and moulds to your foot. But if you’re in a hurry to wear them in, here’s how to make the process easier.
Step-by-Step:
How To Break In Leather Shoes
Step 1: Make Sure The Size Is Right
Is it better to buy leather shoes bigger or smaller? Neither. The best pair is one that fits just right from the start. Aim for a thumb’s width of space between your toes and the end of the shoe. For pointed styles, your big toe should end roughly where the point begins to taper.
If you’re unsure, we can help - fitting shoes is what we do best. Chat with us online, call, or visit one of our stores.
Step 2: Adjust With The Fit Kit
If your shoes have removable footbeds and they feel snug, switch them for the thinner footbeds in our Fit Kit for extra room. Too loose? Add the forefoot padding under the original footbeds for a secure fit.
Shoes with built-in footbeds can be fine-tuned with our Magic Gel Inserts, which minimise space and push your heel back into place. Don’t forget - laces, buckles and straps aren’t just for style; they can be adjusted for the perfect fit.
Step 3: Wear Them Around The House
Breaking in leather shoes doesn’t have to mean blisters. Start slowly by wearing them indoors on carpet. This lets the leather gently soften and mould to your feet before you take them out for a full day.
Step 4: Try Thick Socks to Loosen Leather Shoes
Heat and pressure are your friends. Wearing thick socks with your new shoes at home helps soften leather faster, relieving any tight spots. This method works across loafers, boots, sandals and heels.
Step 5: Use Gel Spots for Pressure Points
If a certain area is rubbing, our Magic Gel Spots are a lifesaver. Apply them inside the shoe where needed for instant comfort while the leather continues to relax.
Breaking In Leather Boots
Boots are designed with more structure, so they can take a little longer to wear in. Try wearing them in short bursts, using thick socks, and walking indoors before a full day outside. The same process applies if you’re wondering how to break in leather boots quickly - it’s all about gradual wear and targeted adjustments.
Breaking In Patent Leather Shoes
Patent leather, with its glossy finish, is more rigid than smooth leather. To avoid cracks, break them in gradually with soft socks, wearing them indoors at first. Gel inserts and heel grips can also help prevent pinching while the leather loosens slightly over time.
Shoe Care: How To Keep Leather Soft and Supple
Once you’ve mastered how to soften shoe leather during the break-in period, proper maintenance will keep it comfortable and looking fresh for years.
Keep It Smooth: Leather Conditioner
Think of this as a moisturiser for your shoes. Conditioner nourishes leather, keeping it supple and preventing cracks.
Serve and Protect: Water & Stain Protector
A light mist creates an invisible barrier against rain and spills, while still allowing the leather to breathe.
For A Final Shine: Black Shoe Wax
Restore colour, remove scuffs and keep your shoes polished with wax and an applicator brush.
Keep In Shape: Shoe Trees
Our Shoe Trees, made from American Red Cedar, absorb moisture, combat odour and preserve the internal shape. Use them regularly to extend the life of your shoes.